Selective Seconds

Welcome to Selective Seconds

Open in Indianapolis since 1997, Selective Seconds Consignment is located on Indianapolis’ southside. With almost 5000 square feet of womens, juniors and accessories, you’ll be sure to find something that suits your style! OPEN DAILY with over 1000 new items arriving each week!

Walk-ins welcome Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday 10-6
Out-of-season clothing and accessories - cash or in-store credit
Current season clothing and accessories - consign, cash or in-store credit

From Our Blog

Nifty Fifty Clearance Sale

Nifty Fifty Clearance Sale Extended Due to Weather

Recycle – Resale – Relax Even shopping has a snow day now and then. In honor of affordable shopping and you staying safe, we are closing today (Sunday), and extending our Nifty Fifty Winter Clearance Sale through Tuesday. And just in case you’re wondering, we still have some boots and scarves, isn’t that nifty? Save […]

Nifty Fifty Winter Clearance Sale

Nifty Fifty Winter Clearance Sale starts Thursday

50% OFF Boots, Coats, Purses, Jewelry, Sweaters… All Of It… 50% Off! 4 DAYS ONLY February 26 – March 1 (Thursday – Sunday) Sneak Peek 25% OFF New Spring Fashions Each day we’ll roll out new Spring racks at 25% off. Enter to Win! Each day of the sale we’ll give away a $50 Gift […]

Spin the wheel

Love is in the air. So are the savings!

Spin the wheel Saturday & Sunday to save! We are stocked full of designer handbags, shoes, jewelry, perfumes, winter sweaters, tops, jeans and more, all at 50-75% off retail. To sweeten our prices this Valentine’s weekend, spin our wheel at checkout Saturday & Sunday to save even more! 100’s of items added each week! Shop […]


Visit us to see what’s in store

Find your new must-haves If you love Gap, White House/Black Market, Chico’s, MissMe, Coach, Sundance, Eileen Fisher, Brighton, cashmere, deisgner perfumes, and more, stop in and see our new arrivals at 50-75% off retail!

Punches for cash

New Rewards Program!

No more frequent buyer cards to punch. No more lost cards. Our software will now track your rewards (It’s your responsibility to give us your name at time of purchase). For EACH $25 spent before tax, you will receive 1 point. Spend $50 earn 2 points, spend $75 earn 3 points, etc. No limit on […]

We need puzzles for kids of all ages!

National Puzzle Day

Thursday, January 29 Help us celebrate by helping others! We are hosting a Community Service project to collect puzzles for Damar Services. No puzzles? No worries. We need board games, too! What next? Bring your donations to our store Thursday, January 29 – Sunday, February 1 and we’ll deliver them to Damar. How can you […]

Just Arrived!

Need Cash? We can help!

We are buying (and consigning) these gently used items: Items we love: Brands we love: Tops Sweaters Cardigans Tunics Layers Active Wear Boots & shoes Handbags Perfumes New makeup New gift items Loft J Crew Chico’s INC Lane Bryant Michael Kors Lucky NYDJ Northface UGGS ​Gucci Anthropologie ​and more! Not sure? Just ask! Items must […]