Selective Seconds

Welcome to Selective Seconds

Open in Indianapolis since 1997, Selective Seconds Consignment is located on Indianapolis’ southside. With almost 5000 square feet of womens, juniors and accessories, you’ll be sure to find something that suits your style! OPEN DAILY with over 1000 new items arriving each week!

Walk-ins welcome Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday 10-6
Out-of-season clothing and accessories - cash or in-store credit
Current season clothing and accessories - consign, cash or in-store credit

From Our Blog

Everyone's a Winner at Selective Seconds

Everyone’s a Winner at Selective Seconds

Shop Thursday-Sunday and save an additional 20% on all sale items (May 26-30) NO COUPON NEEDED – OPEN DAILY PLUS, one lucky shopper will WIN the total amount of their purchase! Shop between Thursday & Monday to qualify. Winner receives their purchase amount (before taxes) in the form of in-store credit.

Calling All Curvy Divas!

Our selection of plus sizes is greater than ever! Now is a perfect time to shop Selective Seconds for sizes 1X thru 3X! Our racks are full, prices are low, and our friendly staff is ready to assist you.

New Arrivals


Good Luck, Rene

Rene’s last day in the store will be Saturday, May 21. Stop in between May 17-21 to wish her well. We will be hosting a small celebration on May 21 from 4 pm to 6 pm. She would love to see each of you before her last day. To the customers of Selective Seconds: It […]

"Just Because" clothing and accessories

“Just because” clothing and accessories

Over 1000+ new items arriving each week. Stop in and see your favorite brands today. Thanks to all our customers for your continued business. Did you know… When you use your consignor account balances for in store purchases, you save an additional 10% off. Shop and save even more!

We’re Bursting at the Seams with Several New Items

The warmer weather is on its way, and we can’t wait to share some of the new arrivals we have in stock. With over 1000 items arriving each week, our inventory is constantly changing. With so many items to choose from, it is so hard to just choose a few. Our staff found a few […]


The Time Has Come to Say Good-bye and Good Luck

For the past 9 1/2 years, Rene has greeted so many of the faces that have walked in to Selective Seconds. During this time, she has built relationships with many of our customers and assisted in finding the perfect look for so many. The time has come for us to say good-bye to Rene as […]