Selective Seconds

Welcome to Selective Seconds

Open in Indianapolis since 1997, Selective Seconds Consignment is located on Indianapolis’ southside. With almost 5000 square feet of womens, juniors and accessories, you’ll be sure to find something that suits your style! OPEN DAILY with over 1000 new items arriving each week!

Walk-ins welcome Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday 10-6
Out-of-season clothing and accessories - cash or in-store credit
Current season clothing and accessories - consign, cash or in-store credit

From Our Blog

Shop for the Gift That Says “I Love You”

You know your mom best, so give her a gift that’s as unique as she is. With many mom-approved items throughout the store, you’ll find the perfect one to celebrate her. To help you out, we have included some of our favorite items. Stop in during Mother’s Day weekend, and you will receive a FREE […]

Selective Seconds Wants to Know… #HowDoYouMom

Our staff not only loves their own moms, but they love their kids, too! Whether their kids walk on two or four legs, they love them just the same. Happy Mother’s Day to the team that keeps Selective Seconds running smoothly every day. Share the love of your favorite mommy photos on Instagram or Facebook […]

Community Angels

Pearls…Pearls…and More Pearls

Pearls pearls pearls…a girl can never have enough – especially if she’s going to the black & white ball… Help us support the 5th Annual Community Angels Black and White Ball event by purchasing your own set of pearls from our store. They sell for $10 each. We will give back $5 for each strand […]

Spring is in the air! And there are fresh deals everywhere

Markdowns Happening Now – Save 30-80% off! The grass is green, the sky is blue and we’re waiting on you to stop in for our spring markdowns! With discounts up to 80%, you’ll surely leave with a spring in your step. We receive over 1000 new items each week, so our inventory is constantly changing. […]

Community Angels

Help Us Give Back to Community Angels

Have you heard about Community Angels? This organization began in Johnson County and continues to give HOPE to families battling cancer and other debilitating diseases and/or illnesses. Selective Seconds is excited to be able to support this organization. Stop in and purchase a set of pearls for only $10. 50% of each purchase will go […]


Getting To Know Our Staff: Cindy

Say hello to Cindy! Cindy is a proud mom of 2 boys (Ryan and Eric) and her grandchild Layla who is 3. She is expecting her newest grandchild, Albert, on May 1. Cindy and her husband Scott are so proud of the responsible and kind men their 2 sons have become, and the good daddy […]


Join Us & Go Green!

April 22 is Earth Day. Sounds like a perfect day to make a difference! Stop in for your free gift from us – just a small token of our appreciation for helping us continue to “grow” our business. When we all make it a priority to go green, our earth will reap the benefits. Your […]