Selective Seconds

Welcome to Selective Seconds

Open in Indianapolis since 1997, Selective Seconds Consignment is located on Indianapolis’ southside. With almost 5000 square feet of womens, juniors and accessories, you’ll be sure to find something that suits your style! OPEN DAILY with over 1000 new items arriving each week!

Walk-ins welcome Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday 10-6
Out-of-season clothing and accessories - cash or in-store credit
Current season clothing and accessories - consign, cash or in-store credit

From Our Blog

yellow balloons, happy faces

No fooling, 90% off one day only!

NO FOOLING! WEDNESDAY ONLY 10am-7pm 90% OFF THE ORIGINAL PRICE OF “LAST CHANCE” ITEMS Look for signs, yellow balloons and happy faces! Plus, SAVE on all our NEW SPRING ARRIVALS. Our racks are packed with your favorite brands, (clothes, shoes, handbags, perfumes, and more) all hand selected especially for you!

Why pay more?

What’s on your list?

Why pay more when you can’t tell the difference? Spring into Our Store We have a wonderful selection of handbags, summer tops, active wear, capris, shoes/sandals & more!

Selective Seconds

New Rewards Program!

No more punch cards to carry. Let us keep track for you! For each $25 spent before tax, earn 1 point. (Spend $50 earn 2 points, etc.). After 10 points, you receive $10 in-store credit. Time is running out to redeem your old punch cards for $2/punch.

Hello Spring

Hello Spring

Our store is packed with new spring arrivals! Whatever your favorite brand, there’s a good chance we have it! We’ve hand picked the best quality, best condition items for you. Save 50-75% everyday off retail. Sizes XS thru 3X. Open daily.

Feeling lucky?

Feeling lucky? Stop in Friday thru Tuesday (Mar. 13-17) and register to win!

We retrieved this gold Kate Spade bracelet from the pot at the end of the rainbow. After discussing over some Irish tea, we voted to give it to a lucky customer! No purchase necessary and no Irish heritage required to enter. And after you enter to win, shop our new spring arrivals where you’ll always […]

New Arrivals

New Arrivals are Here Just in Time!

We have a store full of spring items to greet you this weekend. We have processed over 1,000 new items just this week — here’s a peek!

Nifty Fifty Clearance Sale

Nifty Fifty Clearance Sale Extended Due to Weather

Recycle – Resale – Relax Even shopping has a snow day now and then. In honor of affordable shopping and you staying safe, we are closing today (Sunday), and extending our Nifty Fifty Winter Clearance Sale through Tuesday. And just in case you’re wondering, we still have some boots and scarves, isn’t that nifty? Save […]